A Place for Medical Related Jokes, Poetry, Etc, in Journals
January 8 to January 13, 2009 Summary: A peer-reviewed medical journal should publish the highest quality, most transparently reported, most well-written work possible to attract readers, but should it also offer readers lighter fare such as jokes, creative writing, and the like, or does such work undermine the journal’s image?—MW
The purpose of a journal is often quoted to be "To inform, educate and to entertain its readership". I wonder if many journals fulfill the last purpose. How many of you publish medical related jokes, anecdotes, poetry, etc? "Other Departments" of Lancet, "Fillers" of BMJ, and some JAMA pages may be of this kind. But they are regular features even in these journals, and they are never seen in the majority of other journals.
Space constraint cannot be the excuse. In many journals, each article starts on a fresh page and the left-over space at the end of the preceding article can be used for this purpose. They are the most well read pieces. In BMJ, I might have skipped some original articles, but not a single filler. When readers cherish them very much, why should we deny it? Is it because of our unfound fear that such pieces may spoil the "serious look" of the journal?
V Raveenthiran
Associate Editor, Indian
Journal of Surgery
________________________
The Journal of General
Internal Medicine regularly publishes creative writing—poetry and prose—in
a section called “Reflections.” Every other year (more or less), we also
sponsor a creative writing contest. We have two Deputy Editors dedicated
entirely to reviewing creative writing submissions, of which we received 87
manuscripts in 2007.
Bill Tierney
________________________
Tobacco Control
has run cartoons bannered "The Lighter Side" since our launch in
1992. They are hugely appreciated by most of our readers who often use them in
lectures. We have an intrepid cartoon editor who fiinds material on-line from
all over the world. We generally pay, but occasionally find cartoonists who are
happy to have their work run free or for a token fee. If anyone wants to know how
our cartoon editor goes about finding material, his name is Stan
Shatenstein <shatensteins@sympatico.ca>
Simon Chapman
Commissioning Editor for Low & Middle Income Countries:Tobacco Control
________________________
Gaceta Sanitaria
publishes a section bannered "Collective Imaginary" with examples of
our collective imaginary (a poem, a proverb, a song...) related to health and
public health with a small (creative) comment. The section (one page per
issue) is appreciated by readers. Half of the pieces are spontaneous
submissions, whereas the rest are "induced" by the section's editor.
You may browse them at http://www.elsevier.es/revistas/ctl_servlet?_f=7026&seccionid=13002118
Esteve Fernández
Editor-in-Chief, Gaceta
Sanitaria (Journal of the Spanish
Society of Public Health)
________________________
We are very much interested to publish microbiology-related
jokes etc in our journal. Would someone come forward?
Ashraful Alam
________________________
I don’t think to putting medical jokes in a scientific journal
is a good idea, as it loses its sanctity. Medical jokes look good in magazines
related to health not to a indexed journal. You hardly find such things in journals
with high impact factors.
SM Kadri
________________________
Thank you, Dr Kadri, for your opinion (I personally feel
closer). But I think medical-related jokes (editors obviously find logical
placement) can refresh our emotions, which we should not ignore like robots!
Certainly, impact factor should be kept in mind.
Ashraful Alam
________________________
The importance of humour in all aspects
of life, including medicine, does exist. In scientific journals, jokes
have to be based on scientific facts and principles. I think Dr Kadri might
have thought that the jokes will be as ordinary as those published in other
magazines and books. In India, one Science
Reporter is published every month. Nice cartoons—based on various
scientific facts, principle and current events—are published, and it creates both humour and scientific knowledge.
A good idea indeed.
Sadhu Charan Panda
Editor, Journal of Community
Medicine
________________________
Come on, you lot! Lighten up! Humour is an important part of
medicine, and if you can't think of a joke for Dr Alam, it is time you asked
someone to tell you one! Here's a really terrible one from me to make those
jokeless people realise they don't have to try hard to offer a better one...
What did the mould say when he was refused entry to the party?
Let me in! I'm really a fun guy [fungi]!!
I guess you're going to be suffocated with dumb jokes now, let me start them off for you!!! Sydney is a real party place!
Vivienne Miller
